Introduction

The Clare Castle Hotel at Raymond Terrace was established around 1861.

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 28 November 1940, page 4, provided the following overview of the history of the hotel written by their correspondent J. Hanlon, prior to the opening of the new hotel, which replaced the old premises:

‘The erection of a new hotel, which will take the place of the old premises, revives memories of other days in Raymond Terrace. The ‘Clare Castle’ would be one of the oldest buildings in the town. It was first built owned and licensed by Mr. Patrick O’Donohue, who named it ‘Clare Castle’, after County Clare, Ireland, where he was born.

The old building would be erected nearly a century ago. The whole property consisted of a very large block. The frontage starting from the Oddfellow’s Hall, down to Kimes’ large shed, which was known as the Sheffield Hall. The depth was over 500 feet, a small farm. From particulars received from members of my family, Mr. O’Donohue, (who was my grand uncle) retired from the hotel business about 1878 or 9. It was then taken over by John O’Malley (Malley), and run by him for some time.

About 1884 my parents who became the owners of the property, moved in from ‘Leigh ‘ Farm’. They carried on the business for about 25 years. Several improvements were made. Buildings were created on each side of the Hotel. A saddler’s shop was tenanted by Charlie Rowthorn and a two storied premises was let to the Northumberland Banking Co. ……

The hotel and all these buildings were sold by public auction after my father retired. The hotel was purchased by the late Phil Millgate, who made still further improvements and extensions. He conducted the business in a very satisfactory manner, and being a sport, he organised wood chopping contests on a large scale, quoit matches, and foot running.

After many years he sold out owing to illness and the hotel was taken over by the late Alf Maher, of Williamtown who, after a short period sold out to a well-known hotel family D. J. (Jim) Morgan, son of David Morgan, who was a licensee of the Junction Hotel and Cosmopolitan Hotel. Mr. and Mrs. Morgan conducted the hotel during the period of the last great war [1914-1918] and it was often remarked by travellers and people in general that the service and management was equal if not better than many on the north.

Mr. and Mrs. Yarsley were the next licensees to take on about 17 years ago, but after, a few years it was taken over by Mr. Grisdale. Last but not least, we come to the present owners Mr. and Mrs. Ted Thomson [as at November 1940] , who as most of your readers know, have managed it right through the depression years in a very creditable manner.’

Building on the summary above, this paper traces key events in the history of the Clare Castle Hotel, which remains in business.

The reports cited refer to the premises as either an inn or a hotel.

Meeting held at the Inn to support a Catholic newspaper – 1868

The Freeman’s Journal of 29 August 1868, page 7, reported:

‘A meeting of the subscribers and persons friendly to the “Freeman,” [Catholic newspaper] was held last week at the Clare Castle Inn, to take into consideration matters connected with the “Freeman” and with the intended prosecution of the paper, by the Attorney-General. Several resolutions were passed the substance of which was to support at all hazards, the only Catholic and independent paper in the colony, and from which Catholics, and especially Irishmen, can get authentic information of what is passing in the native land and be informed also of the passing events throughout the Catholic world.’

Gold displayed at the Inn from the Harrington gold diggings – 1878

The Freeman’s Journal of 4 May 1878, page 9, reported:

‘Brockley, Watson and party arrived at Malley’s Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace, from the above diggings on Sunday, 28th, carrying with them 400 oz. of gold, the result of their first crushing from 130 tons of stone; the stone was not selected. They inform me that they have still better stone landed awaiting an opportunity of having it crushed. They make complaints about the press not reporting the great progress made by the several parties now working at the Barrington.’

Licensee required to improve accommodation at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1882

The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser of 3 June 1882, page 6, reported on a decision of the Raymond Terrace Licensing Court:

‘An application from John Malley, of the Clare Castle Inn, was opposed by Mr. Sub-Inspector Duffy, on the ground that the accommodation was not up to the minimum standard. The applicant was allowed till the 30th November to complete alterations, and file statutory declaration.’

Clare Castle Hotel before later enlargement, circa 1883 [The Newcastle Sun – 24 January 1951]

New licensee approved – 1883

The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser of 24 April 1883, page 4 reported on the following decision of the Raymond Terrace Licensing Court:

‘Renewals of the following licences were granted: John Hanlon, Clare Castle Hotel.’

Application by John Malley to update the premises of the former ‘Hunter River Hotel’ – 1883

Advertisement placed by the former licensee of the Clare Castle Inn regarding his plans to update the former ‘Hunter River Hotel’ Raymond Terrace [Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser – 16 October 1883]

Meeting of the National Party held at the Clare Castle Inn – 1892

The Australian Star of 15 February 1890, page 6, reported:

‘Thanks to the energy and zeal of our many Protectionists here a hurried meeting [of the National Party] was called on Thursday to consider what stops should be taken in connection with the visit of Messrs. E. Barton. O.C., M.L.C., and Mr. R. A. Price. At the hour appointed they rolled up from far and near to Alderman Hanlon’s Clare Castle Inn, Miller’s Forest being particularly well represented. There were present: Messrs. Eennix, May, Melgate, Hanlon, M. Donoghue, Callaghan, Flynn, Adams, and others. It was decided to meet the visitors at Hexham on Friday and give them a hearty welcome to the Terrace.’

Political Rally on the verandah of the Clare Castle Inn – 1894

The Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate of 19 April 1894, page 3, reported:

‘Mr. W. Ellinsworth, who hails from Wallsend, addressed a meeting of the electors from the balcony of the Clare Castle Hotel on Saturday night, and announced himself as a candidate for Gloucester at the ensuing election. The meeting was well attended and was presided over by Mr. M. Hanlon. The candidate declared himself in favour of an elective Upper House, female suffrage, local government, and a supporter of measures, not men. He would sink the fiscal issue.’

Inquest held into a death in the grounds of the Clare Castle Hotel – 1896

The Maitland Daily Mercury of 2 September 1896, page 4, reported:

‘Mr. Chas. McIntyre, District Coroner, and a jury of twelve, conducted an inquest at Hanlon’s Hotel today, touching the death of a man named James Mulholland, who was found dead in an outhouse on the hotel property at nine o’clock this morning. J. Adam, sen., was appointed foreman of the jury, who proceeded to view the body, after which the following evidence was adduced. —

John Hanlon, hotelkeeper, residing at Raymond Terrace, deposed: Deceased came to my hotel seven or eight days ago and has been here off and on since then; he never complained to me and had the appearance of being healthy; I never knew him to be the worse of liquor; when he had a glass he generally took beer; he came to my hotel yesterday (Sunday) morning; I saw him at four o’clock in the afternoon, and afterward undoing his swag in the room where he now lies, and he said he was going to stop there; he had his own blankets; I said to my son Jim, has he had anything to eat, and my son said he would bring him into tea, which he did, and the man ate a hearty meal. I did not see him afterwards till I saw his body about 9 o’clock this morning. I recognise the body as that of James Mulholland, whom I have known for 12 years. I do not know whether he is a married man, or a man with any means; I don’t think he had any money. — To the Coroner: I have not seen him under the influence of liquor; he was quite sober when I saw him last. —

James Hanlon, labourer, residing at Raymond Terrnco, deposed: I saw deceased about 4 o’clock yesterday (Sunday) afternoon. He asked me if he could sleep out in the room where he had his swag and I said yes. I asked him if he would have something to eat, and he had his tea. He then went out and made his bed in the room in the yard and he went to bed. I told him how to fasten the door and left him. He had roast meat and bread for tea, and he appeared to be in low spirits, but never complained of being ill. He appeared to me to be a man who was suffering from the effects of drink. I have known him 8 or 9 years. I went to call him about 9 o’clock this morning, and getting no answer I burst the door open and found him lying dead. There were no signs of a struggle. —

William Lynch, butcher, deposed — I know the deceased James Mulholland; I have seen the body lying in the outhouse; I have known him for 28 years; he was never married to my knowledge; I do not think he had any property, or money; I last saw him alive at about dusk yesterday (Sunday) evening; he appeared to be sober; he never complained of being ill; he was deficient of one leg.

Senior-constable Steele, stationed at Raymond Terrace, stated — This morning about 9 a.m. Mr. John Hanlon, licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel, called at the police station and informed me that a man had been found dead at his place. I sent Constable McMinn down to the Government medical officer, Dr. Meredith, to inform him to go down as soon as possible and see the body. I then proceeded to where the body was lying and saw it in an outhouse. There was no appearance of any struggle; I was present when Countable McMinn searched the clothing taken off the body. A letter was found thereon, which I produce.

The letter is written from Gunnedah, and dated August 2nd, 1896, and is addressed to “Dear Uncle,” and is signed “M. M. and J. R. Jackson, affectionate niece and nephew.” I have communicated with the officer in charge of police at Gunnedah to see these people but have not received any reply. The letter was addressed “Mr. James Mulholland, Swan Reach, Hinton.” —

Dr. J. B. Meredith, Government Medical Officer, deposed: About 9.30 this morning I was called by Constable McMinn to see deceased. In my opinion he was dead six or eight hours. I made an external examination of the body and saw no injury or marks on it; since then I have made a postmortem examination of the body. On removing the skull cap, I found the vessels on the surface of the brain congested. On opening the chest, I found the back of both lungs inflamed, the heart contained a little blood, and the mitral valves diseased. On opening the abdomen, I found the liver very much enlarged, gall bladder also enlarged and distended, kidneys also enlarged. I am of opinion that death was the result of syncope of the heart accelerated by the conditions stated. The condition of the liver and kidneys was in my opinion due to intemperance. The jury returned a verdict, “That deceased died from natural causes.”

Premises of the Clare Castle Inn advertised for sale or lease – 1898

Advertisement published for the sale or lease of the Clare Castle Inn premises [Maitland Weekly Mercury, 16 April 1898]

Clare Castle Hotel premises and other Real Estate advertised for sale – 1905

In August 1905, John Hanlon advertised his considerable portfolio of real estate holdings, including the Clare Castel Inn, for sale, as he desired to retire and possibly return to the ‘old country’.

Lot 2 allotment of land on which was built the Clare Castel Hotel was described in the advertisement as follows: ‘Situated in Port Stephen street, having a frontage of 86ft by a depth of 140ft, attached to which is a Lucerne Paddock and Garden 190ft by 231ft, or the whole forming a lot containing 1 and a half acres of land (more or less), and upon which is built the ‘Clare Castle’ Hotel, at present held under lease, expiring on 9th February, 1908, by Mr. P. Milgate. The building is built of wood and iron, and contains 11 rooms, exclusive of bar, with every convenience, such as stabling, sheds, good water, etc., etc., and at present time commanding a good rent and a most flourishing trade.’

Advertisement for sale of Clare Castle hotel and surrounding real estate [Newcastle Morning Herald, 19 August 1905]

The Wingham Chronicle and Manning River Observer of 9 September 1905, page 3 reported:

‘Mr. Geo. S. Hill, Raymond Terrace, reports having disposed of the Clare Castle Hotel, by auction on Saturday last, to Mr. Philip Milgate, its present lessee, for £1010. Also, the adjoining property to Mr. Jas. Hanlan, for £150. Both properties are regarded as cheap.’

Clare Castle Hotel as promoted Milgate’s Hotel reflecting the name of the licensee, Phillip Milgate – circa 1905

Death of Phillip Milgate, licensee and owner of the Clare Castle Hotel – 1907

The Gloucester Advocate of 7 December 1907, page 9, reported:

‘The death is announced of Alderman Philip Milgate, late Mayor of Raymond Terrace. Deceased gentleman was a native of that riverside town on the Hunter and was landlord of the Clare Castle Hotel there for many years. Genial, courteous, and considerate, he made many friends, and when it became known some time since, that he had contracted that disease, consumption of the throat, regret and sympathy for him was universal. He tried every remedy without success and gradually succumbed to its ravages. His funeral was one of the largest ever witnessed at the Terrace, the Rev F. A. Nealon officiating at the grave. He leaves a widow and six in family, to whom we extend our sincere sympathy.’

Grave of Phillip Milgate at Raymond Terrace Cemetery [Australian Cemeteries Index]

Stables to be erected at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1913

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 12 September 1913, page 3, reported:

‘The ordinary monthly meeting of the [Raymond Terrace] Municipal Council was held in the council chambers on Wednesday night of last week. …. [Correspondence was received] from Russell and Chapman, giving notice of intention to erect stables at rear of Clare Castle Hotel.’

Advertisement for the Clare Castle Hotel- 1913

Advertisement placed by the licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel, D. J. Morgan [Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser, 10 October 1913]

Clare Castle Hotel promoted as Morgan’s Hotel, reflecting the name of the licensee, John Morgan, circa 1915 [University of Newcastle, Living Histories]

Tenders called for repairs and painting – March 1920

Advertisement for tenders to paint the Cosmopolitan Hotel and Clare Castle Hotels at Raymond Terrace [the Newcastle Sun – 13 March 1920]

Tooth and Company acquires the premises of the Clare Castle Hotel – March 1921

In March 1921, Tooth and Company, a major brewer of beer in New South Wales, acquired the premises of the Clare Castle Hotel from the previous owner, the Castlemaine Brewery and Wood Bros & Company of Newcastle.

Raymond Terrace Clare Castle Hotel Licensee Card, 1920 – 1926 [State Archives NSW]

Music Teacher available for consultation at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1922

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 1 September 1922, page 3, reported:

‘Mr. Yarsley, who has commenced a class for boys desirous of learning any brass band instrument, may be consulted at the Clare Castle Hotel. Parents should take the opportunity of seeking advice, free of charge, from a champion euphonium and cornet soloist.

Advertisement placed by A. K. Yarsley, teacher of all brass band instruments [Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser – 8 September 1922]

Death of William Grisdale, licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel – 1924

The Newcastle Sun 3 November 1924, page 3, reported”

‘The death occurred on Friday last of Mr William Alfred Grisdale, licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace. He had been in business in Raymond Terrace for over ten years. He left a widow and four children. The late Mr. Grisdale was well-known in Newcastle, being a brother of Mr. John Grisdale, secretary of the Newcastle Jockey Club and son-in-law of A. J. Yarsley, of Merewether. The funeral took place on Saturday at Sandgate and was well attended.’

New licensee for Clare Castle Hotel – 1924

The Newcastle Sun of 29 December 1924, page 4, reported:

‘Transfer of license has been granted from Mrs. Grisdale to Timothy Ryan, of the Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace.’

Clare Castle Hotel – 1924 [Australian National University, Open Research Repository]

New Licensee for Clare Castle Hotel – 1925

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 28 August 1925, page 3, reported:

‘Mr. Ryan, who has been the licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel for the past nine months has sold out to Mr. Hodgson, of Parramatta, who took up the license from last Friday, when the transfer was affected at the Court.’

New Licensee for Clare Castle Hotel – 1925

The Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate of 3 November 1925, page 6, reported:

‘The following licenses were transferred at the West Maitland Licensing Court by Mr. M. Nott, P.M., yesterday: Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace, from William W. Hodgson to John Wood.’

New licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel fined by a Court – 1926

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 5 March 1926, page 2:

‘On Friday 19th, at the local [Raymond Terrace] Police Court John Woods, of the Clare Castle Hotel was fined £1 and 8/ costs, for allowing a prohibited person on his premises. The defendant said he ordered him off the premises, after he was informed by the Sergeant that he was a prohibited person, and refused to serve him with liquor.’

New Licensee for Clare Castle Hotel – 1926

The Maitland Daily Mercury of 10 May 1926, page 4, reported:

‘The license of the Clare Clastic Hotel at Raymond Terrace was transferred from Joseph Woods to Edward Thompson by Mr. M. H. Cleeve, P.M., at the West Maitland Licensing Court this morning.’

Ashton’s Circus performs in the Clare Castle Hotel paddock – 1926

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 26 November 1926, page 3, reported:

‘Ashton’s circus will be here on Saturday night and will show in the Clare Castle Hotel paddock. The name is sufficient to guarantee a good show. Prices are as usual.’

Ashton’s Circus advertisement [Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 26 November 1926]

Clare Castle Hotel licensee promotes Wood-Chopping competition – 1930

The Dungog Chronicle of 29 April 1930, page 2, reported:

‘A £20 handicap woodchop will be conducted at the Clare Castle Hotel (registered ground) Raymond Terrace on Saturday 3rd May. The event will be carried out under the N.S.W. Association with which registration has been effected. Entries are 10/each and will close on day of chop. Mr. T. Thompson of the Clare Castle Hotel is the promoter and Mr. M. Leddon, handicapper. Twelve-inch peppermint logs will be used.’

The Dungog Chronicle of 13 May 1930, page 4, further reported:

‘Mr. Ted Thompson, of the Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace, put on a £20 wood chop on Saturday week, in the paddock at the rear of the hotel, which had been made a registered ground. The chop was popular, the attendance good, in spite of the rain which fell in heavy showers during the afternoon. Mr. Mat Leddon arranged and controlled the chop, and everything went along very satisfactorily. The most expert axemen in Australia were present.‘

Ted Thompson’s team wins Tug-of-War – 1932

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 18 February 1932, page 3, reported:

‘At the recent sports on the riverbank reserve on January 24, Ted Thompson’s Raymond Terrace team won the Tug-of-War, and are now holding the silver cup. which is in possession of the Clare Castle Hotel proprietor for the time. If the team can win it next year it becomes their property.’

Owner of the Clare Castle Hotel to update land registration – 1932

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 10 March 1932, page 3, reported:

‘The Registrar-General informed Council that Tooth and Co. were applying for a Real Property title for the Clare Castle and Cosmopolitan hotels and asked if there were any objections. Council did not object.’

Christmas greetings from the licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel – 1934

Christmas greetings from Ted Thomson, the licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel [The Maitland Mercury – 13 December 1934]

Tenders invited for improvements to the Clare Castle Hotel – 1935

The Newcastle Sun of 30 September 1935, page 2, reported:

‘Tenders are invited for the erection of new lavatories, concrete footpaths, and bathrooms at the Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace, …. for Messrs. Tooth and Co. Ltd. Plans and details may be obtained at the office of the Castlemaine Brewery, Hunter-street West. Tenders will close on Monday.’

The Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate of 16 November 1935, page 22, further reported:

‘Extensive repairs are being carried out at the Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace, for Messrs. Tooth and Co. Ltd.’

Post Renovation Report on the Clare Castle Hotel – 1935

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 19 December 1935, page 3, reported:

‘The Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace has enjoyed the popularity this past year that good management and good service always secures. The hotel is noted for its hospitality; a warm welcome always awaits old friends. The quality of the liquors is always of the highest that can be bought and always sold true to label. The chefs are capable and put on the table the best of viands and none go away complaining. The hotel has just been renovated and is now better in appearance and condition than at any period of its history.

The old Clare Castle has a wonderful record. Away back there before most people now alive were born, one John Donohue had the license, then a few years later, John Hanlon known for his honesty and straight going was the licensee; then a son-in-law Phillip Milgate, a keen sport and good chap had the care; after him the late Alf Maher, and then James Morgan, son of Davy, who, successfully ran the Cosmopolitan Hotel. The Clare Castle then had a few quick occupiers, till Ted Thomson happened along and built the old hotel up to a standard equal to anything on the road. He gives good service and the public know it. If you want a Christmas hamper or accommodation at any time you can rely on the way he will treat you.’

Sale of the paddock behind the Clare Castle Hotel to the Council – 1936

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 23 July 1936, page 3, reported:

‘A special meeting of the [Raymond Terrace Municipal] Council was held on Monday night last, to discuss the report of the Finance Committee on the letter received from Messrs. Tooth and Co. re the sale of the paddock at the rear of the Clare Castle Hotel.

The terms of sale by Messrs, Tooth and Co. were that they required a reservation of 40 feet at the back of the hotel; also, that the Council should drain the surplus water at the rear of the hotel premises; that a 10 year’s booth right be granted Tooth’s during which time only Tooth’s ales should be sold on the ground. That the purchase price should be £125.

The Finance Committee turned this offer down as too drastic. The price of the Land was considered too high without any of the concessions asked for. They thought that as Tooth and Co. would financially benefit from the establishment of the show and sports ground, they could have been more reasonable in their terms. Any future leases of the hotel premises held by them would be substantially influenced by the proximity of the Show and Sport ground to their hotels.

The Committee decided to report to the Council that the offer be rejected. In dealing with the question the Council adopted the report and decided to interview the manager of Tooth and Co. in Sydney but will intimate to the Newcastle manager that they are adopting this course. If no satisfactory sale is made after consultation with Tooth end Co., then an application for resumption will be put in. Only such of the area as is necessary will be resumed, which will be about one-half of the paddock. Some of the owners in the area agreed to sell at the Valuer-General’s valuation. Others are asking much beyond the valuation. These portions too will be resumed if other arrangements cannot be made. Council decided to accept the tender of Messrs. A. F. Hall and Co. at. £12/1/ for a survey of the area, provided that the price included any drainage levels required.’

Tenders called for exterior repairs and painting to the Clare Castle Hotel -1937

Tenders called by Tooth & Co Limited, for the painting of the two hotels they own at Raymond Terrace [Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser, 10 June 1937]

Sir Earl Page attends Dinner at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1939

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 23 February 1939, page 4, reported:

‘Sir Earle Page, accompanied by Hon. V. C. Thompson, Assistant Minister for Commerce, visited Raymond Terrace on Friday, and delivered an address on the possibilities of settling migrants from Northern Europe on coastal low-lying areas. The meeting was held in the Oddfellows’ Hall, presided over by Dr. Meredith. President of the Shire, and there was a fair attendance. …..

The party was entertained at dinner at the Clare Castle Hotel, where about 30 joined in. Sir Earl Page and Mr. Thompson were the guests of the Shire Council and the Chamber of Commerce. The dinner was an enjoyable affair and formalities were dispensed with. Mrs. Thompson [wife of Edward Thompson, the licensee] had provided a most enjoyable menu, and her part of the evening was most creditably performed, and at the close of the dinner, the President and company heartily thanked her for her excellent service. Mrs. Thompson expressed her thanks for their kind remarks and was well thanked in knowing that they had appreciated her efforts. Several Speeches were contributed by the various members of the party during the evening. Sir Earle and Mr. Thompson left immediately after they had dined and returned to Gosford.’

Sir Earl Page who served as the 11th Prime Minister of Australia from 7 to 26 April 1939, in a caretaker capacity following the death of Joseph Lyons

Clare Castle Hotel to be rebuilt on a new site in Raymond Terrace – 1940

The Dungog Chronicle of 30 August 1940, page 4, reported:

‘The Port Stephens Shire Clerk (Mr. C. L. Monkley) received the plans and specifications on Monday for the Clare Castle Hotel, to be erected at the corner of William and Port Stephens streets, Raymond Terrace. The building, in brick and of two stories, with tiled roof, is estimated to cost £13,000. The architect is Mr. C. C. Ruwald, Martin Place, Sydney.’

The Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate of 7 September 1940, page 12, also reported:

‘Two weatherboard: cottages have been demolished and removed from the land in Raymond Terrace, on which the Clare Castle Hotel is to be erected. These old structures were landmarks of the town. Tenders for the new building have close. The estimated cost is £13,000.’

The Maitland Mercury of 13 September 1940, page 4, further reported:

‘Tooth’s propose to erect at Raymond Terrace, on the corner of William and Port Stephen’s-street, a new hotel. This will take over the license of the Clare Castle Hotel lower down in Port Stephen’s-street. The application was before the Shire Council for the necessary permission for the work to be gone on with. The architect stated that the estimated cost was about £13,250.

There would be 10 bedrooms, public and saloon bar, parlour, two lounges, three garages, man’s room, bathrooms, urinals, 3 toilet blocks, boiler room, servery, kitchen block, cellar, etc. Septic tanks will be installed. The building, which would be of a pleasing modern design, would be of brick of two storeys with a tile roof. The block of land has for many years been unoccupied. The building will be opposite the Commercial Bank on the opposite corner.’

Hotel license to be transferred to the new Clare Castle Hotel premises – 1940

The Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate of 26 September 1940, page 9, reported:

‘A special Licensing Court will be held at Raymond Terrace on Tuesday to deal with an order conditionally granting the removal of the licence of the Clare Castle Hotel to premises to be erected in Port Stephens and William Streets.’

Licensee appointed for New Clare Castel Hotel – 1941

The Cessnock Eagle and South Maitland Recorder of 23 May 1941, page 5, reported:

‘Visitors to Raymond Terrace in the future will be able to renew their acquaintance with Mr. Ted Odgers at the Clare Castle Hotel. Ted is now the proprietor of that well-known hotel, and if he gains the same popularity as proprietor of the Clare Castle as he did when a Cessnock Rugby league player, everything augurs well for his success.’

Advertisement placed by the new licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel, Ted Odgers [The Cessnock Eagle and South Maitland Recorder, 30 May 1941]

Former premises of the Clare Castle Hotel to be sold – 1941

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser reported:

Messrs. T. S. ELkin and Co. report having sold the old Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace to Mr. W. Berry at a. satisfactory figure.’

Advertisement for a hairdresser who had commenced business in the former Clare Castle Hotel premises [The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser – 14 February 1946]

New Clare Castle Hotel officially opened – 1941

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 4 September 1941, page 4, reported:

‘On Thursday afternoon last the New Clare Castle Hotel, which stands on the corner of William and Port Stephens Streets was opened for business. Dr. Meredith occupied the chair, and in the presence of a good crowd read apologies from Mr. R. L. Fitzgerald, M.L.A. Crs. Parish, Tranter, and Upton regretting their inability to attend. Also, one from Mr. J. P. Hanlon, of Hamilton a former Mayor of Raymond Terrace, and a son of one of the early proprietors of the hotel. He wished The new Clare Castle every success.

Cr. Meredith said when he first came to Raymond Terrace there were five hotels. Now they were down to three. He was pleased to see the improvement, and the public would appreciate it. He wished Mr. and Mrs. Odgers every success in the new hotel. He asked Mr. Fairweather for the Chamber of Commerce to say a few words.

Mr. Fairweather said the Chamber of Commerce wished success to the new Clare Castle Hotel. He complimented the owners, the architect and the contractor on the design and construction of the new hotel. It was one of the best country hotels and equal to any in the city and would attract visitors to the town and they could rely on a good service. The proprietor and his wife were excellent people and did everything they could for the town. He wished them a long and successful career in the new hotel.

Mr. Trippett representing the brewery said he apologised for Messrs, Watson and Benson. The old hotel had served its day and was worn out so they decided to give Raymond Terrace something better. He congratulated Mr. Ruhal, (Architect) and Mr. Parry (Builder), on the fine job they had made of it. He felt proud to think they had given the citizens such a good building. The place right through was sound and carried out all the latest known in bars and hotel appointments. He thought too, they had made no mistake in entrusting the management to Mr. and Mrs. Odgers. They would see everything was right and he wished them every happiness and success.

Cr. Meredith them asked Cr. Russell the President of the Shire to declare the hotel open Cr. Russell said he thanked Mr. Odgers for asking him to open this fine hotel. He referred to the vacant block that had so long remained idle on the corner now occupied by the hotel, and which presented such a fine appearance and was a wonderful asset to the town. He congratulated the architect on his design and the contractor on the faithful work he had done. Everything inside the hotel was designed for the comfort of the public in all possible ways. He trusted the hotel would be as successful as the proprietor and its owners deserved. The public would find every comfort and would appreciate it. He declared the new hotel open and wished every success to the Clare Castle Hotel.

Mr. Odgers, proprietor, said he thanked Cr. Meredith for presiding, and Cr. Russell for declaring the hotel open, and also all those who had come along to join in the ceremony. He thanked the brewery for providing such a fine hotel and thought it would bring additional trade to Raymond Terrace. Mrs. Odgers and himself and staff were out to give the best service they could to the public and he hoped they would earn the appreciation of the public. He then invited all who wished to make an inspection of the hotel, and to accept their hospitality at the bar. There was a large attendance including many ladies who made an inspection of the hotel.

The building is of brick and cement tiled roof, amply lighted with the latest design of light giving windows; 10 comfortable rooms, with lounge room, sitting rooms etc. The public bar is roomy and a horseshoe design capable of allowing 100 customers to be served without loss of time. A saloon bar is also roomy and convenient. Toilet rooms are also provided adjoining the bars. The yards are concreted, a substantial garage is available, and garden plots have been bricked in on both frontages to the streets.

A gigantic cool room is provided, which gives service for any quantity of food or liquor. The ventilation has been made a fine art and should provide fresh currents of air all through the spacious rooms. Septic tanks provide an up-to-date sanitary service, equal to any in the powered areas, and in this respect the public is well catered for and is one of the important features of the Hotel. All throughout the building silky oak has been adopted for the doors, doorstops, cupboards etc. and is a beautiful finish. A complete hot and cold-water service is installed throughout, and electric clocks set in the walls, denotes the passing hour.

Right throughout the house new furniture, beds, bedding, floor coverings etc. have been put in thus making the hotel the equal of any in larger centres and even in advancement in the latest equipment. The footpaths are concreted all-round the building and makes the frontal appearance a fitting finish to the substantial proportions of the hotel.’

New Clare Castle Hotel – June 1942 [Australian National University Open Resource Repository]

Horseshoe style bar at the new Clare Castle Hotel [Decoration and Glass, Vol 9, no. 6, March-April 1944, National Library of Australia]

Dining room at the new Clare Castle Hotel [Decoration and Glass, Vol 9, no. 6, March-April 1944, National Library of Australia]

Premier W. J. McKell attends luncheon at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1946

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser, of 2 May 1946, page 3, reported:

‘On arrival, at Raymond Terrace, Mr. McKell was met by a representative gathering of the residents, including Crs. Parish, Russell, Morgan and Lantry of Port Stephens Shire, Cr. P. McLean, President of Lower Hunter Shire, Messrs. R. L. Fitzgerald, and W. Howarth, Ms. L. A., Mr. J. P. Abbott, M.H.R.; Mr. Frank Edstein, President of the Chamber of Commerce and others. Cr. Parish, as President of the Shire, extended a cordial welcome to the Premier and said they were pleased at the interest he had taken in mechanised farming, and had done much towards increasing the productivity of the land at a time when increased productivity was needed. Unfortunately, the Premier arrived at a time when the district was suffering the ravages of a disastrous flood and was looking bad, but the Premier he thought would be able to realise from his own observation what the man on the land had to endure at times. ….

The Premier was entertained at luncheon, at the Clare Castle Hotel, by the Port Stephens Shire and the Rural Co-operative Society.’

Sir William John McKell, Premier of NSW 1941 – 1953

Masonite Corporation Dinner held at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1947

The Maitland Mercury of 31 May 1947, page 4, reported:

‘The staff of the Masonite Corporation at Raymond Terrace met at the Clare Castle Hotel to tender a dinner to Mr. Sam Rodgers, who has been selected by the directors for a visit to America and the Continent to inquire into the latest methods of wood processing.’

Illegal bookmaker fined for operating at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1848

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 5 February 1948, page 2, reported:

‘An S. P. [starting price] better was, fined £20 [at the Raymond Terrace Police court] for betting in the lavatory at the Clare Castle hotel.’

Licensee departs from the Clare Castle Hotel – 1949

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 7 April 1949, page 2, reported:

‘The Raymond Terrace sports and other townsmen gave a farewell ceremony to Mr. and Mrs. Ted Odgers, of the Clare Castle Hotel, on Saturday night last, prior to their departure to take over the Continental Hotel, at North Sydney. The function was held in the Soldiers’ Hall.’

New Licensee for the Clare Castle Hotel – 1949

The Maitland Mercury of 11 April 1949, page 2, reported:

‘Mr. and Mrs. G. West and family have taken over the Clare Castle Hotel, Raymond Terrace. They came from London months ago.’

Advertisement placed by the licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel [The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser – 20 August 1953]

Prime Minister attends luncheon at the Clare Castle Hotel – 1953

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser, of 29 October 1953, page 4, reported:

‘On Tuesday the Prime Minister, Hon. R. G. Menzies accompanied by Mrs. Menzies and Miss Heather Menzies visited Raymond Terrace and officially opened the new Shire Chambers erected by the Port Stephens Shire. After the ceremony the party were entertained by the Shire Council at luncheon at the Clare Castle hotel. About 70 guests were present.’

Prime Minister Robert Menzies at Raymond Terrace officially opening the Port Stephens Shire Council Chambers [Newcastle Morning Herald – 27 October 1953]

New Licensee for Clare Castle Hotel – 1954

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser, of18 March 1954, reported:

‘It is reported that Mr. Alf. Ward, of Tea Gardens has become the purchaser of the license of the Clare Castle Hotel. The license was only transferred about a week ago from Mr. George West to Mr. Sandrall. Mr: Ward is well known to most people in the Tea Gardens— Newcastle area, having been proprietor of of the bus service from Tea Gardens to Newcastle. Mr. Ward recently disposed of this service to Foggs.’

Advertisement placed by new licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel, Alf. Ward [Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser – 15 April 1954]

The Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser of 3 June 1954, further reported:

‘At the Raymond Terrace, Court on Friday last, A. Ward, of the Clare Castle Hotel was granted a permit to supply liquor with meals.’

Advertisement placed by new licensee of the Clare Castle Hotel, Alf. Ward [Raymond Terrace Examiner and Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Advertiser, 13 October 1955]

Concluding Comments

The Clare Castle Hotel has continued to trade in its new location to the present day. It has undergone several refurbishments since it was constructed.

Information on the history of two other Raymond Terrace Hotels are also published on this website can be viewed at the following links:

Early History of the Junction Inn Hotel at Raymond Terrace – Port Stephens

Early History of the Cosmopolitan Hotel at Raymond Terrace – Port Stephens

Papers on the history of Raymond Terrace district are also published on this website and can be viewed at the following links:

Early History of St. Brigid’s Catholic Church – The First 100 Years

War Loan Tank Drive Visits Raymond Terrace, Port Stephens – 1918

A Tour of Millers Forest and Raymond Terrace, Port Stephens – 1918

Raymond Terrace Municipal Council Jubilee Celebrations – 1934

Journey to the Vineyards of the Lower Hunter and Port Stephens Districts – 1865

Millet Growing and Broom Manufacture in the Raymond Terrace District – Port Stephens

A Story of the Raymond Terrace District of Port Stephens in 1893

Researched and compiled by Kevin McGuinness

November 2026

Leave a Reply